Bayport-Blue Point Claims First New York State Division II Title

November 12, 2025 | By Brian Coleman
Bayport-Blue Point is the 2025 New York State Division 2 Champions

The Bayport-Blue Point Phantoms captured its first ever New York State Public High School Athletic Association (NYSPHSAA) Division 2 Girls Tennis Championship with a 4-1 victory over Edgemont at the USTA Billie Jean King National Tennis Center. 

“We knew it wasn’t going to be given to us, and that we had to go take it,” said Lily Castka. “If we weren’t focused, it wasn’t going to happen. We knew we had to go out there and play our best.”

With that mindset, the Phantoms dispatched of Honeoye Falls-Lima 5-0 in the semifinals to reach the NYSPHSAA Championship for the second straight season and face off against Edgemont. 

Eden Romano joined Bayport-Blue Point’s singles lineup late in the season, and delivered some key victories in the playoffs

Eden Romano, who clinched the Long Island title for her team earlier in the week, won 6-1, 6-1 at second singles to kick off the scoring in the final for Bayport-Blue Point.

“I’m super impressed by Eden. She was a big doubles player all season for us and joined our singles lineup late,” said Bayport-Blue Point head coach John Selvaggio. “That decision paid off.”

Evie Romano & Leila Rogers then won 6-2, 6-4 at first doubles to bring the Phantoms within one win of the state title. 

Leila Rogers & Evie Romano celebrate after winning at first doubles in the state championship

In fitting fashion, that win would come on the first singles court from Lily Castka, the Suffolk County singles champion who had previously sealed the team’s county championship. 

Castka raced her team through the finish line, winning 6-1, 6-3 to win the third point for Bayport-Blue Point, and clinch the state title. 

“I was definitely a bit nervous towards the end of my match, but I just told myself to keep breathing and get through it,” Castka said. “It feels amazing. I don’t think it’s something our school has ever done, so it’s cool to be a part of that, especially the clinching match.”

Lily Castka capped off her junior season with the clinching win in the state championship

At third doubles, Jordana Heller & Julie Wellems won 6-4, 6-2 to round out the scoring for Bayport-Blue Point. The lone point for Edgemont came from the second doubles duo of Isabella Jee & Seren Fowler who won 2-6, 6-2, 7-5. 

“I’ve been proud of this team from the start, and they did a phenomenal job today,” Selvaggio added. “They stayed calm, cool and collected; got fired up when they needed to, but stayed in check when they needed to. It’s a testament to the hard work they put in during the season and during the offseason. We had a grueling schedule towards the end of the season that got us ready for these moments. 

And every week, someone new steps up. They all depend on each other, and we’re like a family. No family is perfect, there are things we work through as a group, and at the end of the day, they love and respect each other and that’s all that matters. They all did their part today.”

Castka added:

“Everyone on this team does what they are supposed to do and it pays off. It’s definitely something we are proud of, and we wouldn’t be able to accomplish this without everyone on the team.”

CLICK HERE TO SEE PHOTOS FROM BAYPORT-BLUE POINT VS. EDGEMONT


Brian Coleman
Senior Editor, Long Island Tennis Magazine
Brian Coleman is the Senior Editor for Long Island Tennis Magazine. He may be reached at brianc@usptennis.com.
USTA NTC
Century

Long Island Tennis Magazine March/April 2026